"With shows like Project Runway and Top Chef, the Bravo cable channel skillfully packages the fantasy that gifted amateurs can break into the big time. But make no mistake: It is a fantasy."
nymag.com/news/features/35538/
nymag.com/news/features/35538/
-
Re: "The Near-Fame Experience"
Tue, August 14, 2007 - 11:35 AMIt's unrealistic to think that fashion isn't a business, but truly sad that genuine talent doesn't get you ahead. If shows like this are really trying to discover and promote new talent, they need to support and mentor them properly. Banana Republic and Jay McCarroll don't have anything in common.
I had instructors in school who were amazing and loved what they did. They wanted nothing more that to pass on their knowledge and experience.
I would love to see smaller, less known but successful designers be mentors to these winners.
-
-
Unsu...
Re: "The Near-Fame Experience"
Tue, August 14, 2007 - 12:25 PMWhile I think Jay is great, I'm so over his bitching about PR. He had his own showing in Bryant Park last year. You can't expect to be an instant success from just showing one collection, especially a collection that no one wanted. It took Todd Oldham and Isaac Mizrahi years of showing collections before their businesses took off. Anna Sui built up her own label before even starting to show so she had a built-in market. If Banana offered him contacts at production facilities, he should know how to make it work (no pun intended). Even I would know how to get production on a line, and I'm not even in the fashion industry.....
Santino said his income has quadrupled and what's-his-name is doing bridal for another label and Andrae is looking to get a position as a designer for another company. None of them are bitching and they're approaching their opportunities with some sense. It seems like Jay feels like he was promised something he clearly was not. -
-
Unsu...
Re: "The Near-Fame Experience"
Wed, August 15, 2007 - 11:53 AMAnd to be fair to Bravo, hardly anyone from any reality shows on any channel ever become successful. Aside from a handful of American Idol contestants and if you consider becoming a better-known porn star after being on Flava of Love, most of these people disappear as quickly as they emerged. Girls on the Next Top Model franchise don't become successful working models, the winners of the Apprentice don't become major business players, no one becomes a Hilton, actresses don't make it after being on The Starlet, winners of Project Greenlight don't have box office success, the winner of Wickedly Perfect did not become the next Martha Stewart, etc. -
-
Re: "The Near-Fame Experience"
Thu, August 16, 2007 - 7:02 PMXnow, how do you remember all these show!!
i think the first winners are the biggest whiners. Adrienne still complains about ANTM, yet i see those who didn't marry a Brady (and get another reality show from it) or who didn't win ANTM in tv commercials all the time. YaYa is in a new Oil of Olay commercial now, and isn't she the one who had bad skin!
-
-
-
